Saturday, November 20, 2010

Coyotes, Rabbits and Western self-loathing

The other day I posted http://www.lawrencehelm.com/2010/11/europe-world-war-ii-suicide-and-jason.html, entitled "Europe, World War II, Suicide, and Jason Bourne." Some Leftists responded to this note, but they were only interested in my comments on suicide. The implications for Europe and whether there still exists a residual negative effect from World War II and whether Europeans feel less secure from not having an effective military didn't interest them -- at least not enough to cause them to comment. These Leftists were interested in whether Europeans might be committing suicide at a greater rate than Americans. It galled them to think this might be true.

They didn't care so much about the larger suicide, the one that Bat Yeor, Oriana Fallaci, Mark Steyn, Claire Berlinski and a host of others bemoan, the so-called slow suicide of European nations -- that is, the unwillingness of Europeans to produce a sufficient number of children to replace the elderly who are dying off. The Leftists preferred discussing the matter of Europeans literally killing themselves now, rather than whether European nations might dwindle out of existence later on. The idea that any European might be driven "by perceptions of cultural malaise" to commit suicide, was, to quote Billy Blogblather "just silly."

Blogblather has engaged in "fashionable self-loathing guilt over supposed Western crimes like racism, imperialism, and colonialism" (to quote Thornton again) so he can hardly object to that assessment. As to praising one's own European culture as preliminary to inducing immigrants to integrate, "how can it be presented as an attractive alternative [to the culture the immigrant has left] and its unique goods celebrated when its public face is one of decadence and trivial pleasure, and when its own intellectuals are eager to voice their hatred of its achievements?"

Biologists tell us that every species has a survival strategy. Coyotes are very good at catching rabbits, but rabbits procreate so abundantly that it doesn't matter. Both survival strategies are excellent. Coyotes will never run out of rabbits to eat, but neither will they be able to eat rabbits out of existence. As to the human survival strategy, we know quite a lot about what has worked in the past. We band together in tribes or larger groups and fight against rival groups. The best fighters survive. The poorest fighters die off. We also have strong beliefs in our religion. If we lose faith in our religion we die off (witness the Roman complaints addressed in Augustine's City of God), we die off. Our hugely complex Liberal Democracies, if we thought about them in this traditional survival-strategy sense, could be considered a great success. We have defeated most of our enemies and seem to have the potential for defeating the rest of them, but our "intellectuals are eager to voice their hatred" of Liberal Democracy's achievements.

The current Western malaise is no new thing. Our Specie's history is replete with examples of tribes, city states and nations deciding they weren't going "to war no more." The Romans regularly decided that internal matters were more important than preparing themselves to defend against a threatening neighbor and paid dearly for their unpreparedness. In modern times France is an example of a nation that largely turned away from war in the face of a seriously threatening enemy. They had a larger army than Germany, but their will to defend themselves didn't match the will of the Germans to conquer them. Has France learned anything from their failure? It doesn't seem so. They have done their best to infect the rest of Europe with their pessimistic philosophies.

[Returning to Thornton] "Of course, for Muslim immigrant children, their attraction to Western popular culture, freedom, pleasure, and material affluence creates a division within their souls, leaving them riven with guilt and doubt. But this wound can be spectacularly healed through martyrdom in the path of Jihad: 'By means of suicide bombing,' Dalrymple concludes, 'the bombers overcome moral impurities and religious doubts within themselves and, supposedly, strike an external blow for the propagation of the faith.'

"Yet in the face of this threat, Europe for the most part has chosen the road of appeasement, like the Europeans of Raspail's novel seemingly content to watch their magnificent civilization evolve into Eurabia, a culture in which Islam and its religious law, sharia, will more and more displace the Judeo-Christian and classical goods of the West -- individual rights and autonomy, democracy, independent thought, everything that has delivered freedom and prosperity to millions of people."

Friday, November 19, 2010

Inaccuracy of officially reported suicide statistics in Europe

Whether one obtains greater accuracy by invoking a European or non-European source for European suicide statistics is interesting. Who has the most to gain by misrepresenting these statistics? Thornton used a non-European source. It is apparently well known that accurate suicide statistics are difficult to obtain. Witness this UK problem:

"Br J Psychiatry. 1975 Apr;126:301-8.

Suicide in Dublin: I. The under-reporting of suicide and the consequences for national statistics.

McCarthy PD, Walsh D.

Abstract

This study of suicide in Dublin during 1964-1968 from coroners' records was undertaken to estimate the discrepancy between coroners' verdicts, the national suicide statistics compiled from them and the clinical assessment of probability of suicide by psychiatrists examining the same records. The large difference in numbers of suicides deriving from the two approaches has considerable implications for national suicide statistics, and these have been briefly considered. From the findings presented we believe that we are justified in concluding that: (a) there are real differences in national suicide rates, at least between Ireland, England and Wales, and Scotland, and (b) the Irish suicide rate is low, though not as low as official statistics suggest, and (c) the discrepancy between official and "true" suicide rates in Ireland is greater than in England and Wales and in Scotland.

PMID: 1156735 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

See also, http://www.jstor.org/pss/25566296

Abstract

Suicide is underreported for a number of reasons and the reliability of the official rates is subject to error from variation in defining and reporting cases-the kind of inaccuracies encountered when ascertaining cases in studies of mortality from any cause. . . .

I admit to being opposed to the EU Project. I have said as much in previous notes. It didn't surprise me to read Thornton's reference. It would surprise me to learn that this situation is as rosy as official European statistics indicate. 

Interestingly, refusing to have children is a form of national suicide. It is more difficult to hide the accuracy of that statistic.

Europe, World War II, Suicide and Jason Bourne

In taking a small break from Atkinson's The Day of Battle, The War in Sicily and Italy, 1943-1944, I resumed reading Bruce Thornton's Decline and Fall, Europe's Slow-Motion Suicide, and ran across the following, ". . . a recent poll . . . reports that in France, 29 percent of those polled felt optimistic about the future, while in Germany only 15 percent did so. Meanwhile in . . . Iraq, 69 percent were optimistic that things will [improve]. Likewise a 2003 Harris poll found that while 57 percent of Americans are satisfied with their lives, only 14 percent of the French, 17 percent of the Germans, and 16 percent of the Italians are. Suicide rates are equally revealing: in many European countries, suicide is the second leading cause of death, after accidents, and France's suicide rate is about twice that of the United States', as are Belgium's, Luxembourg's, Finland's Austria's, and Switzerland. Rates of emigration from Europe to America, even as hardly any Americans immigrate to Europe, also suggests that the 'European Dream' is not so attractive to many of those who live it."

The first thought I had was that it may not be a good thing for the U.S. to emulate Europe's Utopian ideals too closely. Perhaps it is Europe's paternalistic policies that have turned Europeans into something like Nietzsche's "last man," "men without chests," and left them hopeless.

My second thought had to do with the association of World War II and the present European despair. We in America seem to be convinced that Post-Traumatic stress, for Americans, is far more prevalent than was believed in the past. Perhaps that is true of Europeans as well. If any continent is entitled to the Post-Traumatic Stress syndrome it is Europe. Most of the Europeans who actually fought or suffered during World War II are dead now, but their children and grandchildren are living, and the sins (at least some sins) of the fathers are still visited upon the children of the third and fourth generations. Perhaps what Europe has touted and writers like Robert Kagan have ridiculed, European Utopia, is actually a form of escape, an ideal created to permit these children to cope with their fathers' sin.

Robert Kagan in his Of Paradise and Power, America and Europe in the New World Order scoffed at Europe's pretensions. Their belief that they could handle all their problems with diplomacy and "soft power" failed miserably in the former Yugoslavia. Much to their chagrin they had to request "obsolete" America to get them out of that trouble. Also, their pretense of adhering to a higher international law was seen to be threadbare during the build up to the resumption of the Iraq war. France's commitment to Iraq had nothing to do with international law. Thornton writes, "In the same deal that sold the nuclear reactor [destroyed by Israel] to Iraq, France sold another $1.5 billion worth of weapons, including the Mirage F1, France's most advanced jet fighter at the time, along with an air-defense system, surface-to-air missiles and advanced electronics. This was just the beginning of French arms sales to Iraq, which reached $20 billion worth of the most sophisticated weaponry, including 'thousands of HOT and Milan anti-tank missiles, Roland 2 air defense systems, and Gazelle helicopters.' As Kenneth Timmerman notes, 'Iraq was in effect subsidizing the French Defense Ministry.'"

These matters have been discussed elsewhere and there is no need to spend too much time with them here, but it is worth noting that those most responsible for the fostering of the "ideal" of a European Utopia, were conducting business as usual when it came to their own national interests. France, at least France under Chirac, wanted his nation to lead Europe into competition with the United States. While America may have been the "last man standing" after the Cold War, Chirac didn't want the U.S. to remain standing alone for long. He wanted a united Europe, led by France, to stand opposite the U.S. in world affairs. That desire may have inspired Chirac to "remain in bed" with Saddam Hussein longer than the U.S., Eastern Europe, and many nations of Western Europe thought was seemly. Chirac is gone and so is Saddam Hussein, but this "sin," perhaps, is still being visited upon succeeding generations of French children, for if the "ideal" of a European Utopia was a failure if not a sham, then where does that leave the ordinary European? Perhaps he is being cared for paternalistically by European governments, but for what, a high suicide rate?

Several years ago, a nephew, Sean, brought me a box of books from a relative on his mother's side who committed suicide. This relative wasn't someone he knew. The report was that he was a strange man who spent a lot of time playing war games, and the books I "inherited" bore that out. Sean assumed I would appreciate these books because I was interested in history, but these weren't the sort of books I normally read. They had to do with details of European, primarily German, battlefields, weaponry and uniforms. The few books that actually dealt with history were superficial and he probably bought them because of their photographs. Each time I run across one of his books I wonder about him a little. Did he play his war games with others? Did he belong to a war-game club? And did any of this, these war games, contribute to his suicide?

This fellow would have committed suicide before the failure of the European Utopia was quite as apparent as it is today; so I can imagine, if he was something of a war-monger, that the idea that Europe may have done away with war would have left him despondent. If there was no hope for a future threat from a Hitler or of heroics from such generals as Patton and Montgomery, then what was the point of continuing to play these games? But if he had held on a bit longer, he would have learned that history hasn't quite ended, and while the two-part Iraq War wouldn't have challenged his war-gaming skills, it would at least have held out hope for him. Future European Wars weren't entirely out of the question.

Which causes me to wonder whether I have this European ennui all wrong. Perhaps Europeans aren't depressed and suicidal because their Utopia isn't working. Perhaps they are depressed because of their diminished "chests," to borrow Nietzsche's term. Modern sociologists fervently believe that the human genome is as malleable as the canine's and that they can turn man, through clever sociological means, into a peace-loving creature. There is, unfortunately, no more evidence to support that belief than there is for a belief in the European Utopia. Nations may be at peace with each other from time to time, but this doesn't mean that they have given up war. War is still one of the arrows in the quiver of any successful state. That it seems to be missing from the European quiver might incline some unreconstructed Europeans to feel less rather than more secure. That is, a confidence in a nation's ability to defend its citizens probably contributes to a citizenry's feelings that it is safe.

The U.S. took care of Europe's security during the Cold War, but who takes care of it now? Eastern Europeans never quite embraced Western Europe's Utopian ideas and those nations have neither forgotten Russia's threat nor that the U.S. is still capable of confronting Russia if need be. Western Europe is still convinced, at least officially, that soft power works, but that idea probably sits precariously in the minds of Europeans who were raised on stories of World War II violence. It is all well and good to disarm Europe's people, but who is going to disarm Europe's enemies?

But, some Europeans may argue, Europe has no enemies. How well, I wonder, does such an idea sit in the psyches of the "third and the fourth generations" of those who sinned in World Wars I and II? I'm reminded of the movie, The Bourne Identity, in which Jason Bourne has lost his memory. Bits and pieces come back to him and eventually he learns that he was an assassin for the government. "You do remember, don't you Jason," his former boss yells at him, and at that moment Jason does remember. His reaction is to grab his former boss and yell back he doesn't want to do it anymore. He then rather inconsistently threatens his boss with violence if he should send anyone after him. In Europe's case only the mildest threats are possible. If any foreign nation comes after Europe in some way, then they will use "soft power" against it -- trade restrictions primarily, I suppose.

The marginally recovered Jason Bourne is no longer an assassin, but he does fight against those who try to kill him, and he is very good at it. But at the end of the third movie, after he has defeated or exposed all his known enemies, he is still on the run. He doesn't know that there is anyone coming after him, but he intends to stay "on the run," because man is a warlike creature and there will always be someone, eventually, to come.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Anglo-American-Westernism and Courage

Two years ago I read the first volume of Rick Atkinson's "Liberation Trilogy," An Army at Dawn, The War in North Africa, 1942-1943. I just started his second volume, The Day of Battle, The War in Sicily and Italy, 1943-1944. In his Prologue he discusses the events leading up to the agreement between Britain and America, committing them, ultimately, to a cross-channel invasion of France -- "Overlord."

In May 1943 the British and Americans seemed at loggerheads about what to do next. The Americans wanted to take the war to Germany immediately; which is what Stalin had been begging for. The British, on the other hand wanted to first attack the "soft underbelly," Italy. What difference would it make to Stalin whether the invasion began in Italy instead of in France -- as long as it forced Germany to pull some of its divisions out of Russia?

The Americans got what they wanted: a commitment to a cross-channel invasion in 54 months. The British got what they wanted, an immediate attack against the "soft underbelly" in Italy.

"Perhaps the greatest achievement of the men meeting at Trident was not sketching of big arrows on a map but rather the affirmation of their humanity. This was their true common language: the shared values of decency and dignity, of tolerance and respect. Despite the petty bickering and intellectual fencing, a fraternity bound them on the basis of who they were, what they believed, and why they fought. It could be glimpsed, like one of Brooke's beautiful birds, in Churchill's gentle draping of a blanket on Roosevelt's shoulders; and in their grim determination to wage war without liking it."

"During a British embassy luncheon on May 22, Churchill, fortified with whiskey, declared that he expected 'England and the United States to run the world. . . . Why be apologetic about Anglo-Saxon superiority?' The bemused vice president, Henry A. Wallace, accused the prime minister of advocating 'Anglo-Saxondom uber Alles,' Churchill waved away the charge. 'We Anglo-Saxons . . . are the only ones who really know how to run the show.'"

COMMENT: Previously, I read about the Battle of Delium in Hanson's Ripples of Battle. Socrates fought as a hoplite in that battle, which the Athenians lost. He distinguished himself by not fleeing in panic as most of the Athenians did. Instead he conducted a fighting-retreat while protecting Alcibiades and Laches. Plato, in his dialogue Laches has Socrates discuss the meaning of "courage." But since "courage" is a virtue, Socrates thought that this "virtue" should be defined first. Since no one seemed up to the task, Socrates declared that he couldn't define it either. I liked Socrates a lot better when I was an undergraduate. Now he annoys me. Everyone at the dialogue agreed that Socrates was courageous at Delium, but when Socrates moved the discussion over into the definition of terms, everyone admits that they can't define "courage." And yet they have, I want to tell them: See Socrates! He was courageous at "Delium." If they used history rather than philosophy, they would have a good working definition of courage. This is how traditions are built. This is how our Anglo-American tradition was built. This is why Atkinson can write and be understood by all except the most obdurate Leftists and Philosophers. We have shared values of "decency and dignity, of tolerance and respect" and we know what those abstract words mean because we have fleshed them out during the hundreds of years of our history.

Leftism and some schools of philosophy see little of value in our history. A word must be turned into a principle applicable to all people everywhere to have any value. Nonsense! We can't answer for all people everywhere, but we can have an idea of who we are and how we arrived at what we hold dear. "Courage" can't be defined or explained unless one can do it philosophically; some schools of philosophy would have us believe. Nonsense! We do not learn as the philosophers pretend. We learn by example. Look at what Socrates did at Delium: that is courage. That is how we learn. We as a species knew about courage before we had a word for it. "Courage" is a word describing something we know, not something that needs to be defined before we can know it.

It is possible to read of the events at the Trident conference in May of 1943 and conclude that the British and Americans didn't get along, but the disagreements they had about how to conduct the war didn't destroy the affection and respect they had for one another. Brothers with similar histories can disagree in ways that those with dissimilar histories cannot. This is another mistake that Leftists make -- to assume that all humanity shares the same values. It does not. Germany and Japan did not share Anglo-American values during World War II. The USSR didn't share them during the Cold War, and Radical Islam doesn't share them today. Leftists in Britain and America, and the Leftist leaders in Europe operate as though they don't know that. They keep trying to make their theory about a commonly-shared humanity -- meaning a humanity that shares Western virtues as valid for Islam. That hasn't worked, and it won't work. Leftists and some schools of philosophy can produce arguments about why it ought to work, but history and our relative traditions will demonstrate to the commonsensical amongst us that it won't.

Leftists love to pick out evils in our Anglo-American history in order to deflate it, but our history is one of trial and error. We learn from our mistakes. Sure, we once committed the sins the Left likes to describe, but do we still commit those sins? One must almost move into theology to deal with certain of these Leftist accusations. There were, and still are Christian schools of belief that argue that "an unforgiveable sin" can be committed. Traditional Christianity, however, teaches that if one repents and turns from that sin, whatever it is, it will be forgiven. Only a sin that is persisted in will be held against a person.

Willful ignorance is a sin the Left persists in. They should get some of their French philosophers to help them with their error (if such were possible). The facts are available. They can be understood if faced directly. Perhaps Socrates modesty prevented him from defining "courage" to his friends, but what excuse can the Left produce to excuse their sin?

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

The Lost election, EU Eloi and Iwo Jima

One recalls that Kerry was touted as a European at heart, and more recently that Obama could have been elected as the leader of the EU had he chosen to live there, but, I want to console my Democratic brethren: the EU ideals are probably flawed.

In Decline and Fall, Europe's Slow-Motion Suicide, Bruce Thornton compares European ideals with those of the Eloi: ". . . enthusiastic descriptions of EUtopia remind one of H.G. Wells's Eloi, the 'very beautiful and graceful creatures' whom the Time Traveler from Wells's 1895 novel The Time Machine encounters in his visit to the year 802,701 A.D. The delicate, youthful, vegetarian Eloi live in a seeming paradise, a garden world without work or conflict or government: 'They spent all their time in playing gently, in bathing in the river, in making love in a half-playful fashion, in eating fruit and sleeping.'

"At first glance, the Eloi appear to be the culmination of human evolution beyond primitivism and deprivation, a cheering vision of human progress and our destined utopia of pleasure and leisure. But on closer inspection, certain features are troubling. The Eloi are tiny, only four feet tall, soft and hairless, 'indescribably frail,' like a 'beautiful kind of consumptive.' They have the intellectual level of a five-year old and are 'indolent and easily fatigued.' Worse, they are hedonistic narcissists, casually watching one of their fellows drown without interrupting their play. The Time Traveler realizes that rather than the culmination of human evolution, the Eloi represent the devolution of the human race, now 'decayed to a mere beautiful futility.'

"This realization is sharpened to horror when the Time Traveler learns of the Morlocks, 'bleached obscene, nocturnal Things' that live underground in anti-like collectives and feed on the effete Eloi like 'fatted cattle.' . . . ."

While I am a great admirer of almost anything Japanese, I don't admire what they had made of themselves as we entered World War II. They can be compared to the Morlocks to a large degree: [The following is from page 339 of Manchester's Goodbye Darkness] "The defenders' CO, Tadamichi Kuribayashi -- Holland Smith called him Hirohito's 'most redoubtable' commander -- had been among the first to conclude the banzai charges, once so effective in Japan's earlier wars with Russia and China, were futile against American firepower. Tokyo had warned him that he could expect no reinforcements. He replied that he didn't need them; the air attacks on Iwo had tipped off the coming invasion, and transports had beefed up his garrison to twenty-one thousand men, led by Japanese Marines. Kuribayashi turned his men into supermoles, excavating the hard konhake rock. They built 750 major defense installations sheltering guns, and blockhouses with five-foot concrete walls, strengthened, in some instances, with fifty feet of earthen cover overhead. Under Suribachi alone lay a four-story galley and a hospital cave. Southward from the volcano lay interweaving iron belts of defense. Altogether there were thirteen thousand yards of tunnels and five thousand cave entrances and pillboxes -- a thousand on Suribachi alone."

COMMENT:

Pause for a moment and recall the glowing descriptions of European utopia by Jeremy Rifkin: A "'bold new experiment in living' has arisen in Europe, and . . . Europeans are 'leading the way into the new era.' This 'European Dream' . . . 'emphasizes community relationships over individual autonomy, cultural diversity over assimilation, quality of life over the accumulation of wealth, sustainable development over unlimited material growth, deep play over unrelenting toil, universal human rights and the rights of nature over property rights, and global cooperation over the unilateral exercise of power."

Imagine groups of these EU Eloi watching the Marines on D-Day on Iwo Jima: "The moment they hit the shore they were in trouble. The steep-pitched beach sucked hundreds of men seaward in its backwash. Mines blew up Sherman tanks. Infantrymen found it impossible to dig foxholes in the powdery volcanic ash; the sides kept caving in. The invaders were taking heavy mortar and artillery fire. Steel sleeted down on them like the lash of a desert storm. By dusk 2,420 of the 30,000 men in the beachhead were dead or wounded. The perimeter was only four thousand yards long, seven hundred yards deep in the north and a thousand yards in the south. It resembled Dore's illustrations of the Inferno. Essential cargo -- ammo, rations, water -- was piled up in sprawling chaos. And gore, flesh, and bones were lying all about. The deaths on Iwo were extraordinarily violent. There seemed to be no clean wounds; just fragments of corpses. It reminded one battalion medical officer of a Bellevue dissecting room. Often the only way to distinguish between Japanese and Marine dead was by the legs; Marines wore canvas leggings and the Nips khaki puttees. Otherwise identification was completely impossible. You tripped over strings of viscera fifteen feet long, over bodies which had been cut in half at the waist. Legs and arms, and heads bearing only necks, lay fifty feet from the closest torsos. As night fell the beachhead reeked with the stench of burning flesh. . . ."

After that, it got worse. "The price of the little island had been 25,851 Marines, including 19 battalion commanders. Battle casualties in the rifle regiments had come to 60 percent in the Third Marine division and 75 percent in the Fourth and Fifth divisions. But they had done the job. On March 4 the first crippled B-29 had wobbled into a crash landing on Airfield No. 1. Three weeks later, with the battle still rain in the northern pockets of the isle, Superfortresses began regular runs from Iwo's three fields to Tokyo. Before V-J Day, 2,251 B-29s, carrying 24,761 crewmen, had made successful landings on Iwo's airstrips. One Air Corps pilot who made three of them told a Time reporter: 'Whenever I land on this island, I thank God and the men who fought for it.'"

The Eloi, like Jeremy Rifkin and the EUtopian advocates, would have been horrified to watch the Marines on Iwo Jima. Surely, they would tell themselves, there would be some way to reason with those Japanese. History tells us that there wasn't. The Eloi wouldn't even have tried. They would much rather be eaten.

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Bill Maher, Liberals and The Left

In my previous note, I wrote, "I have heard a number of Leftists, in response to observations like these, define their own positions to say that they don't support Radical Islam "but . . ." and by the time they are done it seems to me that they have contradicted themselves. But watch the Bill Maher clips. Can my favorite Leftist, Billy Blogblather watch the Maher clips and agree with them? I doubt it, and that is the difference. The Blogblathers still support Radical Islam."

BLOGBLATHER'S RESPONSE TO MY CHALLENGE:

I'm not sure what universe Lawrence lives in but it's surely not this one. I have time and time and time again proclaimed my belief that fascism is one of the greatest evils in the world. I have time and time and time again equated Radical Islam with fascism -- just as I equate Radical Christianity and Radical Judaism and Radical national movements such as ETA and the IRA and some groups in South America with fascism. Because I do not believe in the denial of the rights of Muslims in America nor endorse the wholesale slaughter of Muslims does it mean I support Radical Islam (by which I assume you mean supporters of terrorism). I did not support Radical Americanism especially not when it was murdering people in El Salvador and Nicaragua and Vietnam and Cambodia or any of the other countries we terrorized for years. Get your facts straight, Lawrence. I hate fascism regardless of what program it supports.

LAWRENCE:

I live in the same universe Blogblather lives in, but the one I would like to live in is one in which one responds logically to arguments one wants to disagree with. I challenged Blogblather to watch the Bill Maher clip I cited. He did not do that. He didn't respond to anything Bill Maher says. Here is another Bill Maher clip of equivalent import: http://creepingsharia.wordpress.com/2010/05/04/bill-maher-slams-islam-chris-matthews-loves-it-video/

Blogblather doesn't need to "assume" what I mean. He can watch the Maher clips. I applaud Maher for saying he is a proud Westerner and that he doesn't want to see Britain taken over by Islam. He doesn't want to see Western ideals disappear. He values Western ideals, and he mentions separation of church and state, equality between the sexes, protection of minorities, free elections, free speech, and freedom to gather. If Blogblather were to value these Western ideals as much as Maher does, then he would have to reject Islam insofar as it rejects these ideals -- and the only Islamic sect I know of which has no trouble with these Western Ideals is the Sufi.

As to Blogblather's use of the term fascist, someone from Ireland wrote, "In the Mike Leigh film "Life Is Sweet" there is a dysfunctional young woman who hurls the epithet "Fascist!" at anything that provokes her anger. There is a danger of trivialising "fascism" as a notion by over-applying it. It might be better to say that some of these groups share a fascist belief in using force to get their way; but this would not make them fascist anymore than this belief makes the Cosa Nostra fascist. Max Weber was no doubt on the right lines in suggesting a state, including a democratic state, is partly defined by its claim to a monopoly on the legitimate use of force [including its sanction of such force by others (say, by way of self-defence)]; and democratic states can only survive against violent, non-democratic attack by using force to get their (democratic) way. This does not turn a democratic state into a fascist one, unless we are to expand "fascism" to a point where its meaning is so wide that its application becomes vacuous and misleading."

I see something a little different, and it is an example of why I say that Blogblather supports Radical Islam. While saying that he doesn't, he puts it in the same category as "Radical Christianity" and "Radical Judaism" whatever they are. Saying that there is no difference between Radical Islam and Christianity or Judaism is to give it legitimacy it doesn't deserve. That legitimacy comprises "support."

Maher says that there was period in which Christianity was like Islam is today: "It was called the Dark Ages." There are huge differences between Islam and not only the other religions but Western Civilization. Islam does not support the ideals of the West. It can no more sign up to them than Blogblather can sign up to the comments made by Bill Maher.

Maher goes beyond the statements that got Juan Williams fired from NPR, but I suspect Williams would sign up to them. These two individuals I thought were on the Left now show evidence that they are in the traditional "Liberal" camp. The statements Maher made may be politically incorrect today, but they are core Liberal beliefs. You can't be a "Liberal" in the Western sense and reject what Maher says.

Monday, November 1, 2010

Japanese drunken Banzai charges and the atomic bomb

I've been reading William Manchester's Goodbye Darkness, a Memoir of the Pacific War (first published in 1979). This isn't strictly speaking, a history. Manchester at age 55 travelled to all the Islands where the Marines fought to try to get a feel for what it was like in the places he himself didn't fight, and to recapture something of the places where he did.

Victor Davis Hanson in his Ripples of Battle write's that this book by Manchester and one by E. B. Sledge, With the Old Breed "are not merely graphic narratives of combat, but works of literature in their own right comparable to Xenophon's Anabasis, Siegfried Sassoon's Memoirs of an Infantry Officer and Robert Grave's Goodbye to All That."

"Memoir" is a good term for Manchester's book. It is a conflicted mixture of things. For example, here is a tale he tells about Guam. Of the end of the battle, Manchester writes, "Then Lemuel C. Shepherd, Jr., the Marine general commanding the force, ordered an attack across the swamp ahead. By Monday his troops had seized the base of the peninsula, isolating over three thousand Japanese Marines on the tip.

"Discovering that the only road was in our hands and that they could not perforce escape, the defenders staged one of the most extraordinary performances of the Pacific war. They were bottled up in more ways than one. Orote, it developed, was the central liquor storehouse for all Japanese in the central Pacific. There was enough alcohol in its godowns to intoxicate an entire army. The sealed-off troops had no intention of letting it all fall into American hands. Instead, they planned to tie one on and stage the jolliest of banzais.

"As night fell Wednesday they assembled in a mangrove swamp a few hundred feet from our lines. Not only our listening posts but our entire front line, including the Seventy-seventh's artillery forward observers (FOs) heard the gurgling of sake and synthetic Scotch, the clunk and crash of bottles, the shrieking, laughing, and singing. It sounded like New Year's Eve at the zoo. So noisy was the din that artillerymen could calculate the range of imminent targets at the edge of the swamp. At 10:30 P.M., as heavy rain began to fall, the first wave of drunks lurched toward the American lines -- stumbling, brandishing pitchforks and clubs; some with explosives strapped to their bodies; others, officers, waving flags and samurai swords. Shells form the Seventy-seventh's Long Toms landed in their midst. Arms and legs flew in all directions; momentarily there was more blood than rain falling in Marine foxholes. Screaming and milling around, these groggy warriors staggered back into the swamp. A second wave hit shortly before midnight. This time some of the souses penetrated the outposts of the Twenty-second Marines and were thrown back only after hand-to-hand struggles. At 1:30 A.M., with every American infantry weapon hammering at them, the third wave reached our trenches before being driven back. In three hours U.S. artillerymen had fired over twenty-six thousand rounds. The crisis was over. The next morning, Shepherd examined hundreds of the enemy bodies. He recalls: 'Within the lines there were many instances when I observed Japanese and Marines lying side by side, which was mute evidence of the violence of the last assault."

Okinawa, the bloodiest of the Pacific battles, was the last stop before Japan. Hanson writes, "by mid-1945 the desperate Japanese military's aims were quite different from all conventional war wisdom. And so their plans were also very simple: kill so many Americans, blow up or shoot down so many aircraft and sink so many of their ships that the United States -- both its stunned military and its grieving citizens back home -- would never wish to undergo such an ordeal again. After the butchery to come on Okinawa, perhaps these rather affluent and soft Westerners would seek a negotiated armistice from Japan -- and not tolerate another, greater cataclysm on the mainland in pursuit of an unnecessary unconditional surrender. Okinawa , then, was to offer a suicidal lesson to Americans to stop before they found themselves dying in the millions on the beaches of the Japanese Motherland."

In regard to the atomic bomb, Manchester seems conflicted. On page 210 he writes, "You think of the lives which would have been lost in an invasion of Japan's home islands -- a staggering number of American lives but millions more of Japanese -- and you thank God for the atomic bomb."

But when he discusses his visit to Tinian on page 277 he writes, "Today the island's eight hundred Chamorros are largely isolated from a world still struggling with the specter of nuclear weapons. Once a week a supply ship steams over from Saipan, docking beneath a sign which ironically proclaims WELCOME TO TINIAN: GATEWAY TO ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. Mail arrives twice a week, on a boat which takes three hours to cover the three miles from Saipan. A chartered motorboat with twin engines does the job quickly, but once you land you wish you hadn't bothered. There is an air of forbidding stillness on the isle, a desolation unmatched in, say, rebuilt Hiroshima. This is where the nuclear shadow first appeared. I feel forlorn, alienated, wholly without empathy for the men who did what they did. This was not my war. In my war a single fighter with one rifle could make a difference, however infinitesimal, in the struggle against the Axis. . . ."

"Today the coral airstrip from which the Enola Gay took off is abandoned. Dense shrubs grow along its edges. On the runway itself, frogs and snails crawl among broken coconuts and shells of dead crabs. The pit from which the nuclear bomb was hoisted into the B-29's bomb bay has been filled in. Rising from it are a single stark coconut tree and a shrub bearing yellowish blossoms which emit a cloying, sickening odor. A nearby plaque on a three foot stone marker tells the Superfortress's tale, though it does not, of course, note its implications. Standing there, notebook in hand, you are shrouded in absolute, inexpressible loneliness. You can hear nothing; there is nothing to be heard. The sky is implacable. No white birds hover overhead."

COMMENT: One wonders to what extent the Islamists owe their suicide-bombing tactics to the Japanese. The Japanese hoped that if they kept demonstrating their willingness to fight to the death that the U.S. would eventually get tired of them and agree to let them have a conditional surrender. That strategy didn't work. In fact in probably contributed to Truman's decision to drop atomic bombs on them.

Now we have the Islamists using something like those strategies. They hope their ongoing terrorist attacks will force the West to capitulate to their demands. Atomic bombs cannot be used against, but the U.S. has developed drones, smart bombs and extraordinary satellite surveillance to pursue them in ways they couldn't have anticipated.

This "war" is ongoing. They keep on killing civilians and we keep on killing them, and cracks are appearing in the alliance between Radical Islam and the American Left. Perhaps it took Westerners to make some moral "Banzai charges" against Islam. Geert Wilder and Hirsi Ali are examples of that. And subsequently we have had former members of the Left, Juan Williams and Bill Maher, make it clear that they oppose Radical Islam.

I have heard a number of Leftists, in response to observations like these, define their own positions to say that they don't support Radical Islam "but . . ." and by the time they are done it seems to me that they have contradicted themselves. But watch the Bill Maher clips. Can my favorite Leftist, Billy Blogblather watch the Maher clips and agree with them? I doubt it, and that is the difference. The Blogblathers still support Radical Islam. Maher and Williams don't. http://www.mediaite.com/tv/bill-maher-stands-by-mohammed-remarks-i-dont-need-to-apologize-for-being-a-proud-westerner/