Friday, December 3, 2010

On being “better off”

I am content to sleep in regard to political controversy a while longer. I thought I would be able to switch between photography and such subjects as totalitarianism in the same way I have switched between, say, Heidegger and the Invasion of Sicily in World War II. Heidegger was after all alive during that time, and if I wanted to I might imagine what Heidegger thought of the Allied "second front," but photography doesn't relate to anything I've studied recently. So it is difficult to switch from what I've been studying (DSLR related material while I await my eBay purchased two-year-old Olympus E-520) back to an argument with Omar (who seems ready for one).

I could switch back but if I then neglected photography before becoming adept with the E-520 I would feel guilty. A lady in a Ridgeback discussion group, slipping a bit into politics after having wandered off the canine reservation in my blog, was sure I was 'better off' than she was. Well, perhaps now, but I was born during the depression from a blue-collar and farming heritage. I wasn't "better off" then. I enlisted in the Marine Corps during the Korean War, as any Scotch-Irish Jacksonian young man would, but began reading the Classics at 29 Palms after coming back from Korea and deciding that rather than a career with the USMC, I would go to college and do something else.

I suppose I am chafing a bit over this lady's implication (which I may be imagining) that I perhaps inherited something in order to be "better off." I went to college on the G.I. Bill but I was fascinated with the Classics and took courses in Literature, History and Philosophy that would most closely approximate them. And then, when I graduated from college in 1959 with a degree in English, I was certainly not "better off" than anyone that I could think of. My step-father, a truck-driver, had some sense of the sort of degree one ought to get in order to "get ahead," but I insisted on studying what interested me, come what may.

After four years in college and a marriage that in retrospect was not a wise one, I was definitely not "better off" than any one -- at least it didn't seem so, and my step-father was saying "you should have studied engineering." I needed a job but had no idea how to get one; so I went to an employment agency and promised them some percentage of my first month's salary if they could find me a job, and they did. The sent me to Douglas Aircraft Company where I, ironically, was sent to the Engineering Department to turn Engineering proposals into language understandable to the Air Force.

In 1959 I was in a lower rung of the Douglas Engineering department, but an interesting aspect of Engineering was that it was to a substantial degree a meritocracy. They would let you do whatever you could do. Think of Lt. Ripley in Aliens II on the ship with the Marines going off to find out why the colony (that Ripley knew had Aliens on it) wasn't answering. Bored, she asked the Sergeant if there was anything she could do. He looked at her speculatively and answered, "I don't know. Is there anything you can do?" She looked at a robot-looking loader and said, "I can operate one of those." The sergeant waved his hand and let her do it. Perhaps since I had something to prove to my step-father, I worked very quickly and often asked, "Is there anything I can do," and supervisors gave me more and more to do as time went on. Until one day I was indistinguishable from coworkers who had studied engineering in college. I had studied on the job because I was cocky in that meritocracy back then telling the equivalent of Ripley's sergeant that there was nothing I couldn't do.

Was I better off in Engineering in say 1962 after Douglas lost the Skybolt program and I was going to be laid off unless I found another job in Douglas? It was a spooky because I had a profligate wife, a recently purchased house, and a lot of bills. But some of the people I worked with recommended me to the Aircraft division in Long Beach where I would be working on DC-8 proposals and specifications. I didn't feel "better off" then. I had to prove myself in a new department, but I did have the experience of having done that in the Missiles division; so how hard could aircraft be?

It took a successful proposal (the KC-10) to get me out of the Spec Group (by that time Douglas had merged with McDonnell). Once we won that contract I was given a job in "Program Engineering." but I also worked for the KC-10 Program Office. I was given all the work I "could do," and ended up as a kind of assistant to the KC-10 Engineering Director. I seemed "better off" for a while, but then there was a colossal shake up in Aerospace because "the Japanese had gotten ahead of us," so we had to learn new ways of doing things, resign our jobs and compete for the jobs we had or new ones we might want. I ended up as a manager on the T-45, I might have been "better off" after that, but in about a year that program was transferred back to St. Louis because the parent company, McDonnell, needed the work more than we did in Long Beach.

After that I was a manager in the C-17 department, verifying that the ground test results met Engineering requirements. But then some new consultants convinced McDonnell Douglas management that they could get more work out of all departments by hiring young proven managers from other industries. My new manager hadn't a college education but had been a successful manager at some place like Penny's Department Store. I had a lot of difficulty accepting that situation. McDonnell Douglas was at the same time on an "austerity program." They sought by means of these ruthless young managers, to get rid of older more highly paid employees, which I was at the time. I thought my days were numbered.

I might have been in good enough financial shape to take early retirement if I had been able to participate in the McDonnell Douglas savings plan to the maximum extent, but nature abhors a vacuum, and no sooner did I start making more money than Susan's brother began having trouble with his wife. They had a messy divorce, her brother got custody of their two boys, and since her brother was now too depressed to work they came to live with us. At a time when I was convinced I was about to be laid off I got on the internet and discovered that I could afford to live on my early-retirement money and support my brother-in-law and my two nephews if I moved to Tennessee.

The brother-in-law problem eventually blew over. He moved out and got a job, but since I had begun thinking about retirement I looked at my job at Boeing (who had merged with and subsumed McDonnell Douglas) in a more cynical light and began leaning toward retirement. The closer I got to age 65 the less tolerant I was of management rules that I considered illogical or unnecessary. I was the Engineering representative on the C-17 Change Board for the last several years of my employment at Boeing. Those on the board knew that I did a good job, as did the Air Force, but my management back at a remote location wasn't impressed, especially because I wouldn't walk the two miles or so to staff meetings. I was riding a motorcycle back then and didn't feel like walking that far in motorcycle boots. My manager, whom I never met, had no leverage over me after I decided to retire. All I needed to do was to convince Susan that we should sell our house in Garden Grove and move to some more agreeable retirement location like Payson Arizona; which turned out to be more difficult than dealing with my management at Boeing.

After much negotiation (with Susan) we retired to San Jacinto where I took up walking my dogs at the San Jacinto River (which can be seen in the photos I've been posting recently). With the money we got from selling our Garden Grove house we could afford a large two-story house with a view of the nearby mountains out my study window.

I had worked continuously for 39 years at Douglas, which became McDonnell Douglas, which became Boeing, my retirement income, coupled with Social Security, turned out to provide about as much useable income as I had received while working. So I was indeed "better off" than I thought I would be after retirement.

There was always some relative or friend needing financial help while I was working. I naively thought that would end after I retired and was living on a "fixed income," but not so. The Ridgeback lady who remarked that I was "better off" than she isn't expecting anything from me, but certain relatives and friends have made that same observation and do. And as long as they do not have their "needs" all at the same time, and thus far they haven't, we seem to manage -- yes, because we are "better off," but not because I was "lucky" or inherited money. I am "better off," I suppose because I had the Protestant Work Ethic that Max Weber referred to.

Then too there was an intelligence level that enabled me to do all the things my managers had in mind when they said the equivalent of "I don't know. Is there anything you can do?" And that intelligence (according to Herrnstein and Murray) was from 40% to 80% the result of genetics (in which case I can take very little credit for the things I achieved at my job) or almost all the result if environment. In the latter case since I resisted anything authoritative in my environment (until I joined the Marine Corps) perhaps I can take more credit. On the other hand, since I am a Protestant (Presbyterian) in actuality as well as in Work Ethic, I don't have a problem with the idea that whatever skills and talents I have are a gift -- just not a gift I received from family influence or money.

Ridgebacks Trekking

 

Taken with an HP R717 in January 2006

[Double click on photos to enlarge them]

 

HPIM1274

 

HPIM1279

 

HPIM1277

 

HPIM1281

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Four More Ridgeback Photos

HPIM0116

HPIM0520

HPIM1054

HPIM1118

Ridgebacks under the clouds

 

[Double click on photos to enlarge them]

Taken with an HP R717

 

HPIM3522

HPIM3955

HPIM3951

HPIM5360

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Sight hound–seeing

 

Here are four more photos I took with my HP R717.   Double click on them to bring them up to decent size.

I like certain photos without always realizing why I do.  The first is one of my favorites.  It seems to have everything in it, but I can’t explain that everything is.

The second one puzzled me for a time.  The scenery wasn’t that scenic, and Sage wasn’t being terribly photogenic, but then I realized that she was leaning much as the weathered trees were.

In the third Sage seems to be peering around the edge and off into the distance.

In the last one Sage seems to be enjoying herself immensely as she strides past trees and wildflowers

HPIM0500

HPIM3732

HPIM4342

HPIM4410

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Ridgebacks, Schnoodles and Photography

HPIM0435

Many years ago when I first started hiking seriously I looked for a camera that would take any sort of photo I wanted but would still be light enough for a hike.  In aerospace, at least at the time, it seemed I could find an expert on almost anything and I found one who was purported to be an expert on photography and cameras.  He advised me to get an Olympus 35RC; which I did.  I still have it and it still takes gorgeous photos, but it uses film.

When I sought a good digital camera that had some of the same attributes as the 35RC I got an HP R717 – a fortuitous choice.  It didn’t have the flexibility of the 35RC but its “landscape” setting suited most hiking days.  The photo above was taken with the R717.  The format is too small to really examine the photo, but perhaps you can get an idea of it.  Ginger on the left is looking gorgeously wise and Sage on the right very intense.  One can see mountains reflected in the lake. 

I got a little case that fit on my belt and I could whip the R717 out in no time, or walk along with the strap around my wrist ready to catch my Ridgeback girls in dramatic poses, or the clouds through the trees.HPIM3682

Again, I am almost ashamed to present this in this small format, but if one could see it on my 22 inch Samsun computer screen one would I’m sure find it impressive.  HPIM4040

Here is one I especially like.  The girls are walking together, leaving tracks on the sandy river bottom with forever stretching out before them.

But then Susan got Duffy.  I won’t show any photos of him because he doesn’t photograph well, at least not with my R717.  He is a jet-black Schnoodle who is little larger than a dust mop – well he has grown since his dust-mop days.  Perhaps he is 14 pounds now.  He is Susan’s dog but he insists on going along when we go on a walk or hike.  Not only can I not let him loose so that I can take pictures of him with the girls, I fear to let him loose at all.  We have seen coyotes and feral dogs down there.  The girls chase them, but they might chase Duffy.

Furthermore, Duffy who was 6 months old yesterday occasionally lurches against his leash causing me to jiggle my camera if I happen to be trying to photograph something at the time.  My R717 still took excellent photos, but it was five years old and had no anti-shake capabilities.  So I bought what I thought was the modern equivalent, a Canon SD1400 IS.  But unfortunately none of the automatic settings would permit me to take photos that matched those of the R717. 

The SD1400 reminds me a bit of my old 35RC.  It had a built in light meter.  I could activate that to get that information and them use it to set the aperture and shutter speed manually.  While the SD1400 does have a light meter, it merely tells me what aperture and shutter speed it sees and it won’t let me set them automatically, at least not so far as I’ve seen.  I can set the ISO and I’ve been playing with that, and I could play with the white balance more than I have, but I have yet to produce a photo of the quality of my old 35RC or my newer R717. 

I suspect I shall eventually figure out how to take decent photos at the river with the SD1400, but having to guess at what Canon’s symbols mean makes me wonder whether I shouldn’t have gotten an SLR.  My old Olympus 35RC had most of the settings of an SLR but packaged them into a Rangefinder.  Perhaps the SD1400 will end up seeming like that to me, but it doesn’t yet. 

The reason I never considered an SLR before was because as a hiker I was concerned about weight and SLRs were heavier than rangefinders.  But SLRs have gotten lighter and my hikes have gotten shorter; so I’m starting to think about one.

Another thing, I had discussed in earlier notes my plans to get a smaller dog next time – not as small as Susan’s Schnoodle, but perhaps an Airedale or a Standard Schnauzer, but trying to get a good shot of Duffy is causing me to revise my thinking.  I get positive pleasure out of seeing Sage strike a dramatic pose at the river, e.g. HPIM4377

But I doubt that I could get such shots following a dust-mop, even a dust-mop as large as an Airedale.  An Airedale lover will be quick to tell me I can get him clipped before taking him to the river, but I wouldn’t do that.  I’d get him clipped every six weeks or so, and in between he’d look like a dust-mop.

My reason for considering a smaller dog was that I was 76 last month and it would seem that it might be wise to get a smaller dog.  Ridgebacks need to be boosted in to the back seat of my Jeep, and if we are out walking on leash and a cat runs in front of them, they will forget themselves and try to chase after it, even though I have the other end of their leashes.  However, I just met my new doctor.  He checked me over and said, “you do a lot of walking, lift weights, don’t have arthritis, have a strong heart and lungs, you could go back to work.”

I was startled and said, “I doubt that.  I’ve gotten in the habit of taking naps in the middle of the day.” 

He said, “but you could go back to work if you wanted to.”  Again, I was puzzled by why he would say that.  Did he have patients looking for reasons not to go to work?  Was that his standard for judging good health?  I don’t know, but his opinion suggested that perhaps I needn’t give up on the idea of getting another Ridgeback next time.  I shall probably be able to boost one into my Jeep for several years to come.

HPIM3638

Saturday, November 27, 2010

The Bell Curve redivivus

Someone responded to my note http://www.lawrencehelm.com/2010/11/re-are-muslims-lowering-intelligence-of.html with the following:

On 11/26/10 10:01 PM, Billy Blogblather wrote:

Assumptions [made by the authors of the Bell Curve]

Much of the criticism of The Bell Curve has focused on potential flaws in the basic assumptions made at the beginning of the book. William J. Matthews and Stephen Jay Gould list four basic assumptions of The Bell Curve:

  1. Intelligence must be reducible to a single number.
  2. Intelligence must be capable of rank ordering people in a linear order.
  3. Intelligence must be primarily genetically based.
  4. Intelligence must be essentially immutable.

According to Gould, if any of these premises are false, then their entire argument disintegrates (Gould, 1994).  Similarly, in "Science" in the service of Racism, C. Loring Brace writes that The Bell Curve makes six basic assumptions at the beginning of the book:

  1. Human Cognitive ability is a single general entity, depictable as a single number.
  2. Cognitive ability has a heritability of between 40 and 80 percent and is therefore primarily genetically based.
  3. IQ is essentially immutable, fixed over the course of a life span.
  4. IQ tests measure how "smart" or "intelligent" people are and are capable of rank ordering people in a linear order.
  5. IQ tests can measure this accurately.
  6. IQ tests are not biased with regard to race ethnic group or socioeconomic status.

Brace proceeds to argue that there are faults in every one of these assumptions."

----------------------------------------------
Lawrence replies (I believe to the foregoing), but in any case, he dismisses them with
'Yeah, yeah. I read the criticisms at the time, but unlike most of the critics, I also read the book.'
Is it your claim that Stephen J. Gould and C. Loring Brace didn't read the book?

LAWRENCE RESPONDS: As to whether these critics have read The Bell Curve, I think they have read at least to page 23, for on pages 22 and 23 are the assumptions they denigrate. But when I read what Herrnstein and Murray wrote I can hardly recognize it in the critics’ rephrasing. Here is what Herrnstein and Murray actually wrote:

"Here are six conclusions regarding tests of cognitive ability, drawn from the classical tradition, that are by now beyond significant technical dispute:

1. There is such a thing as a general factor of cognitive ability on which human beings differ.

2. All standardized tests of academic aptitude or achievement measure this general factor to some degree, but IQ tests expressly designed for that purpose measure it most accurately.

3. IQ scores match, to a first degree, whatever it is that people mean when they use the word intelligent or smart in ordinary language.

4. IQ scores are stable, although not perfectly so, over much of a person's life.

5. Properly administered IQ tests are not demonstrably biased against social, economic, ethnic, or racial groups.

6. Cognitive ability is substantially heritable, apparently no less than 40 percent and no more than 80 percent.

We can see that Brace is a bit closer to what Herrnstein and Murray actually wrote, but why change it? What Herrnstein & Murray wrote sounds reasonable. What Brace wrote sounds less so, and what Matthews and Gould wrote sounds even less so. In any case drawing conclusions about the entire book based on the first 24 pages inclines me to think no, they didn't read the entire book, but that's just a guess.